Skip to main content

Table 3 Perception of the study participants regarding the traditional insect repellent plants accessibility, affordability, effectiveness and self reported plant specieses, which are scientifically reported and authenticated as insect repellent plants

From: Insect repellent plants traditional usage practices in the Ethiopian malaria epidemic-prone setting: an ethnobotanical survey

S. No.

Scientific name

Respondents using

Is it potentially useful?

Is it accessible?

Is it affordable?

Previously reported or authenticated.

UR (n = 199)

Percenta

Yes

No

Yes

No

Yes

No

1.

Allium sativum

62

31.2

85.4

14.6

80.6

19.4

88.7

11.3

Valerio and Maroli, [29]

2.

Aloe pulcherrima

66

33.2

93.9

06.1

78.7

21.3

68.1

31.9

Bekele et al., [30]

3.

Boswellia papyrifera

98

49.3

65.9

34.1

86.8

13.2

75.5

24.5

Karunamoorthi et al., [17]

4.

Brassica nigra

31

15.6

80.6

19.4

74.1

25.9

93.5

06.5

Bekele et al., [30]

5.

Buddleja polystachya

59

29.7

88.1

11.9

84.7

15.3

77.9

22.1

NA

6.

Carica papaya

56

28.2

78.6

21.4

85.8

14.2

92.8

07.2

Kazembe et al., [31]; Rawani et al., [32]

7.

Citrus aurantifolia

24

12.1

87.6

12.4

75.1

24.9

83.4

16.6

NA

8.

Citrus sinensis

69

34.7

84.1

15.9

94.2

05.8

89.9

10.1

Zewde and Jembere, [33]

9.

Colchicum autumnale

53

26.7

92.4

07.6

88.7

11.3

79.2

20.8

NA

10.

Croton macrostachyus

87

43.8

68.9

31.1

83.9

16.1

72.4

27.6

Karunamoorthi and Ilango, [3]

11.

Cupressus lusitanica

143

71.9

81.9

18.1

78.3

21.7

94.4

05.6

Karunamoorthi et al., [17]

12.

Echinops kebericho

60

30.2

88.3

11.7

95.1

4.9

90.1

09.9

Karunamoorthi et al., [15]

13.

Eucalyptus citriodora

59

29.7

89.9

10.1

84.7

15.3

81.3

18.7

Palsson and Jaenson, [29]

14.

Eucalyptus globulus

112

61.4

85.8

14.2

99.1

00.9

93.7

06.3

Kweka et al., [34]; Palsson and Jaenson, [29]

15.

Justicia schimperiana

57

28.7

92.9

07.1

87.8

12.2

80.8

19.2

NA

16.

Lepidium sativum

51

25.7

90.1

09.9

96.1

03.9

74.5

25.5

Karunamoorthi and Husen, [18]

17.

Ocimum lamiifolium

65

32.7

83.1

16.9

92.3

07.7

95.3

04.7

Bekele et al., [30]

18.

Ocimum suave

61

30.7

83.7

16.3

90.1

09.9

78.6

21.4

Kweka et al., [34]; Seyoum et al., [13];

19.

Olea europaea

58

29.1

84.4

15.6

89.7

10.3

87.9

12.1

Karunamoorthi et al., [15]

20.

Pavonia urens

47

23.7

93.7

06.3

89.3

10.7

80.9

19.1

NA

21.

Ricinus communis

54

27.2

88.9

11.1

92.5

07.5

83.3

16.7

Bekele et al., [30]

22.

Vernonia amygdalina

71

35.7

84.6

15.4

78.8

21.2

84.5

15.5

Onunkun, [35]

23.

Shitab

43

21.7

95.4

04.6

88.4

11.6

81.4

18.6

Karunamoorthi and Husen, [18]

Total

   

1968.2

331.8

1994.8

305.2

1928.1

371.9

 

Percent

   

85.5

14.5

86.8

13.2

83.9

16.1

 
  1. Note: UR: (use-record) the number of the respondents who claimed the use of plant as an insect repellent
  2. aPercent does not add up to 100, because of multiple responses.
  3. bShita is a mixture of various traditional repellent plant parts such as stem, root, resin, leaves and bark. It is widely available in the marketplace in the majority of the Ethiopian towns.
  4. NA: Not available.