Table 3 Errors detected in the studied publications, assessed using comparative methods.
From: Plant identification credibility in ethnobotany: a closer look at Polish ethnographic studies
Author | Name in the publication (with original spelling) | The correct name | Type of mistake/inaccuracy |
|---|---|---|---|
Bohdanowicz [20] | Origanum vulgare | Chenopodiumsp. | L |
Bohdanowicz [20] | Carduus | Cirsium sp. | L |
Gajkowa [26] | cuminum cyminum | Carum carvi L. | L |
Gajkowa [26] | panicum miliaceum | Echinochloa crus-galli (L.)P.Beauv. | L |
Gajkowa [26] | atriplex hortense | Chenopodium & Atriplex spp. | L |
Janicka-Krzywda [30] | Carlina vulgaris | Carlina acaulis L. | ? |
Kantor [32] | Geranium | Dahlia sp. | ? |
Kantor [32] | Iris | Lilium sp.? | ? |
Kantor [32] | Salsola | ? | ? |
Kantor [32] | Selinum carvifolia | Carum carvi L. | I |
Kantor [32] | Sesleria coerulea | Sesleria sadlerana Janka ssp. tatrae (Degen) Deyl? | I |
Kolberg [33] | Hippophae rhamnoides | Salix sp. | L |
Kolberg [34] | Helleborus albus | Veratrum sp.? Vincetoxicum hirundinaria Medik.? | L |
Ochrymowicz [42] | Iris germanica | Iris sp. or Eupatorium cannabinum L. | ? |
Oczykowski [43] | Rumex hydrolapathum | some other Rumex spp. | I |
Ruszel [49] | Plantago major | Plantago spp. | S (the name refers to all the Plantago species) |
Ruszel [49] | Helleborus viridis | Veratrum lobelianum Bernh.? | L |
Ruszel [49] | Carum carvi | Glechoma hederacea L. s.l. | ? |
Ruszel [49] | Thymus serpyllum | Thymus serpyllum L. em. Fr. &Th. pulegioides L. | S (both species are used) |
Ruszel [49] | Tilia cordata | Tilia cordata Mill. &T. platyphyllos Scop. | S (both species are used equally frequently) |
Ruszel [49] | Rubus plicatus | Rubus subgenus Rubus spp. | S (there are a few dozen species of Rubus in this area, R. plicatus is not the most frequent [84] |
Ruszel [49] | Carduus | Cirsium & Carduus spp. | L |
Ruszel [49] | Rumex hydrolapathum | Rumex spp. mainly R. obtusifolius L. | I |
Siarkowski [51] | Thymus serpyllum | Thymus spp. | S |
Sulisz [52] | Origanum vulgare | Chenopodium sp. | L |
Sulisz [52] | Thymus vulgaris | Thymus serpyllum L. em. Fr. or Th. pulegioides L. | I |
Sulisz [52] | Matricaria Chamomilla | Tanacetum parthenium (L.) Sch.Bip. | I |
Sulisz [53] | Acorus calamus | Calamagrostis epigejos (L.)Roth | ? |
Sulisz [53] | Rhamnus cathartica | Staphylea pinnata L. | ? |
Sulisz [53] | Galium cruciata | Euonymus europaeus L./Rhamnus cathartica L.? | ? (L?) |
Sulisz [53] | Ledum palustre | the term bagnięta was used erroneously as it refers to any wooden branches | L |
Szot-Radziszewska [54] | Cicuta virosa | Solanaceae, probably Hyoscyamus niger L. | L |
Szot-Radziszewska [54] | Thymus serpyllum | Thymus spp. | S |
Szot-Radziszewska [54] | Salvia pratensis | Salvia officinalis L. | L |
Szot-Radziszewska [54] | Papaver rhoeas | Papaver officinalis L. | L |
Szromba-Rysowa [55] | Rubus caesius | Rubus subgenus Rubus spp. | S (other Rubus spp. are used more frequently) |
Szromba-Rysowa [55] | Carduus sp. | Cirsium & Carduus spp. | L |
Szychowska-Boebel [59] | Crataegus oxyacantha L. | Crataegus spp. | S (Crataegus monogyna is more frequent) |
Szychowska-Boebel [59] | Crataegus oxyacantha L. | Crataegus spp. | S (as above) |
Tylkowa [60] | Sonchus olearceus L. | Taraxacum sp. | L |
Tylkowa [60] | Rubus plicatus L. | Rubus spp. | S (there are a few dozen species of Rubus in this area, R. plicatus is not the most frequent [84] |
Tylkowa [60] | Malva alcea L. | Alcea rosea L. | L |
Tylkowa [60] | Thymus serpyllum L. | Thymus pulegioides L. | S - T. serpyllum does not occur in the region, the other species is commonly used |
Wawrzeniecki [61] | Thymus vulgaris | Thymus spp. | I |
Wawrzeniecki [61] | Urtica urens | Urtica dioica L. & U. urens L. | S |
Weryho [62] | Vinca major | Vinca minor L. | ? |