Seeds used for Bodhi beads in China
Journal of Ethnobiology and Ethnomedicinevolume 10, Article number: 15 (2014)
Bodhi beads are a Buddhist prayer item made from seeds. Bodhi beads have a large and emerging market in China, and demand for the beads has particularly increased in Buddhism regions, especially Tibet. Many people have started to focus on and collect Bodhi beads and to develop a Bodhi bead culture. But no research has examined the source plants of Bodhi beads. Therefore, ethnobotanical surveys were conducted in six provinces of China to investigate and document Bodhi bead plants. Reasons for the development of Bodhi bead culture were also discussed.
Six provinces of China were selected for market surveys. Information was collected using semi-structured interviews, key informant interviews, and participatory observation with traders, tourists, and local residents. Barkhor Street in Lhasa was focused on during market surveys because it is one of the most popular streets in China.
Forty-seven species (including 2 varieties) in 19 families and 39 genera represented 52 types of Bodhi beads that were collected. The most popular Bodhi bead plants have a long history and religious significance. Most Bodhi bead plants can be used as medicine or food, and their seeds or fruits are the main elements in these uses. ‘Bodhi seeds’ have been historically used in other countries for making ornaments, especially seeds of the legume family. Many factors helped form Bodhi bead culture in China, but its foundation was in Indian Buddhist culture.
As one of the earliest adornment materials, seeds played an important role for human production and life. Complex sources of Bodhi beads have different cultural and historical significance. People bought and collected Bodhi beads to reflect their love and admiration for the plants. Thus, the documentation of Bodhi bead plants can serve as a basis for future investigation of Bodhi bead culture and modern Buddhist culture.
Humans use seeds (include the fruits with pericarps cannot be easily removed, commonly called ‘seeds’) in many ways. Seeds are colorful, durable, and easy to access, so humans have drilled and strung seeds into necklaces and bracelets for thousands of years. The oldest seed ornaments were discovered in Africa and can be dated to the Middle Stone Age (280,000 to 45,000 years ago) . Moreover, due to the variety of medicinal and edible properties of plants and trees, people placed high value on this type of vegetation, and this feeling has continued to modern times . Some people endow beads with specific meaning for averting disaster, developing wisdom, and soothing and relaxing.
Bodhi beads are Buddhist prayer items that have been traditional tools for counting while reciting a mantra, as prayer beads have been used in other world religions. The Bodhi beads are called Pu Ti Zi in Chinese: Pu Ti means Bodhi tree (Ficus religiosa), and Zi means seed; but Bodhi beads are not made of the seeds of a Bodhi tree (Ficus religiosa). The name Pu Ti Zi first appeared in the early medical text, ‘Compendium of Materia Medica’, which referred to the seeds of Coix lacryma-jobi. In addition, seeds of Sapindus delavayi and Sapindus tomentosus were called Pu Ti Zi or ‘Bodhi seeds’ in Yunnan . In modern times, ‘Bodhi seeds’ do not refer to any particular plant but instead refer generally to seeds and the fruits of various plants used to make prayer beads.
Bodhi beads have an important position in Tibetan Buddhism and are very popular in Tibet (the Xizang Tibetan Autonomous Region). The culture of Bodhi beads spread throughout Tibet and other provinces of China, and there are dozens to hundreds of Bodhi beads with different meanings. Recently, people have begun to wear Bodhi beads as a kind of praying or blessing ornament, in addition to functioning as a prayer bead. The Bodhi bead culture has developed in China in the form of cultural supplies, such as writing brushes and ink sticks. Several ‘Bodhi seeds’ of similar size, shape, and pattern are strung into strings of prayer beads. People frequently touch the beads with their hands to make the beads luster like jade due to secretion from human skin. Moreover, the beads are carefully modified to protect from scarring in inappropriate temperature and humidity surroundings.
Ethnobotanists study how plants are used for food and medicine but are also interested in plant adornments because non-mainstream use of plants can reflect relationships between cultures and (uses of) plants in other aspects. Surveys such as that conducted by Armstrong have shown that many botanical jewelries in different places were made by seeds and indicated the high value placed on the seeds [5, 6]. Over 165 plant species used for human adornment in India were identified and listed .
Recently, there has been increasing interest in the commercial value of Bodhi beads, and many books about the culture of Bodhi beads have appeared in China. Although the books and related materials focus on the meaning of each kind of Bodhi bead, almost all publications ignore the question of which plant or plants produced the Bodhi seeds. The beads have been commonly described as ‘seeds of rare plants’, and this description has fostered a belief that the value of Bodhi beads is related to the scarcity of their sources and not to their aesthetic and cultural value. To help correct this misunderstanding, we investigated the plant sources of ‘Bodhi seeds’ or Pu Ti Zi and explored the culture values of Bodhi bead plants.
Surveys were conducted in local markets and e-commercial platforms of six provinces in China: Tibet, Yunnan, Fujian, Zhejiang, Beijing, and Guangdong. Field work was conducted from September to October 2012 and August to September 2013. Barkhor Street (29°39′ N, 91°7′ E) is a famous street circling Jokhang Temple in Lhasa, Tibet, and was the main local market surveyed. The traditional culture and local lifestyle have been well-preserved for more than 1300 years. We choose this market because of the wide variety of Bodhi beads traded there between vendors, pilgrims, and tourists from Nepal, Bhutan, India, and other places in China. It is the most important commercial center, folk-custom heritage, tourist attraction , and shopping center in Lhasa. Other Bodhi bead trading centers were also investigated, including Shangri-la and Kunming in Yunnan, Xiamen in Fujian, and cultural markets and temples in Beijing.
Bodhi beads samples were purchased from Barkhor Street markets and e-commercial platforms. A detailed inventory and related information for the Bodhi beads were prepared from semi-structured interviews, key informant interviews, and participatory observation with traders, tourists, and local residents. In order to access the popularity of Bodhi beads in Chinese markets, various Bodhi beads in 126 shops of six provinces were studied. The number of shops that each Bodhi bead was sold in was counted for an occurrence frequency (OF) calculation; for example, if N shops sold Bodhi bead type ‘A’ (N ≥ 1), then the occurrence frequency of ‘A’ is OF(A) = N/126 × 100%.
All seeds were identified according to morphological characters and geographical origins using standard literatures [9–12] and cross-referenced with herbarium specimens deposited at PE (Herbarium, Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences). A literature review was used to record additional information, including whether the seeds were used as human food, landscape plants, medicine, condiments, or building timber in China and whether the seeds are used for ornaments in other countries [2, 6, 7, 13–24].
Results and discussion
Bodhi bead plant diversity and distribution
Fifty-two types of Bodhi beads were documented (Table 1), made of seeds from 47 species (including 2 varieties) belonging to 19 families and 39 genera. Among them were only one endangered (EN) species (Latania loddigesii – ‘Xian-Zhi’) in IUCN  and two critically endangered (CR) species (Dracontomelon macrocarpum – ‘Grimace’ and Cycas revoluta – ‘Buddha-mind’) in the China Species Red List . The majority of Bodhi seed plants belonged to Arecaceae (12 genera and 13 identified species) and Fabaceae (7 genera and 8 identified species). The genera represented by the highest number of species was Caesalpinia (3 identified species). Most seeds of a particular species can produce only one type of Bodhi bead. However, different degrees of processing of Corypha umbraculifera, Daemonorops jenkinsiana, and Elaeis guineensis can be used to make different types of Bodhi bead. The seeds with 2-, 3- or 4-loculed drupes of Ziziphus abyssinica can be used to make ‘Phoenix eye’, ‘Dragon eye’, and ‘Kylin eye’, respectively. Chinese names of most Bodhi beads are according to the morphological characteristics of their respective seeds; for example, the beads called ‘Moon and Stars’ usually have an ivory surface with small holes (moons) and tiny black dots (stars). Seeds of Caesalpinia bonduc are grayish, shiny, ovoid to globose, and look like the moon; therefore, the name of the corresponding Bodhi bead is ‘Moon seed’.
Three species of Bodhi bead plants do not occur in China: Phytelephas macrocarpa, Caesalpinia major, and Ziziphus abyssinica. Thirty-one species are native to China, with 19 species mainly distributed in tropical and subtropical areas, and the other species widely distributed throughout China. Twelve species have only cultivation types, and most of these species have been domesticated in southwestern and southern China.
Traditional cultural value of Bodhi bead plants
The most popular Bodhi beads and their potential cultural significance
The occurrence frequencies of four types of Bodhi beads reached at least 50%, including ‘King Kong’, ‘Moon and star’, ‘Bodhi root’, and ‘Phoenix eye’ (Figure 1). These were the most popular Bodhi beads in the markets.
The most common Bodhi bead, ‘King Kong’, is made from the fruit of Elaeocarpus angustifolius. ‘Two-furrowed King Kong’ is made from the fruit of Elaeocarpus hainanensis. Elaeocarpus plants are distributed in Hainan, Yunnan, Guangxi, Tibet of China, and other parts of Asia, including Nepal, Bhutan, India, Indonesia, and the lowlands of the Himalayas . ‘King Kong’ may have been the earliest form of prayer bead in India , named ‘Rudraksha’ in the local language, meaning ‘eye of Shiva’ . The furrows of the hard and rugulose endocarp of fruits are important to the rudraksha. Different numbers of furrows represent different meanings. The rough surface symbolizes the austere life expected of worshippers . Five furrows and up to 14 furrows are usual, while others are very rare . Normally, a string of prayer beads is made with 32, 108, or 112 beads of similar size and the same number of furrowed rudraksha seeds. The standard ‘King Kong’ string has 108 Bodhi beads, and this string of prayer beads is widely used by Tibetan Buddhists .
‘Moon and stars’ is a very popular and traditional Bodhi bead in Chinese Buddhism and is the hard and dense seed of Daemonorops jenkinsiana. The ‘Moon and stars’ name reflects the small holes (moon) and tiny black dots (stars) covering the seed’s surface. This species is mainly distributed in the south of China, India, Nepal, Bhutan and Bangladesh. There was no record of the history of this type of Bodhi bead, but we found many old ‘Moon and stars’ beads in Tibet; we therefore speculated that Tibetan Buddhism was influenced by mainland China’s Buddhism.
Seeds of Corypha umbraculifera are used to make ‘Bodhi root’ beads. This species is native to India and Sri Lanka. In India, it is also called ‘vegetable ivory’ and is a traditional tool for carving Buddhist Sutras, such as the famous ‘tale palm’ or ‘tad-patri’ because the leaves are flexible and soft when dry [30–32]. Because of early Indian Buddhist influences , C. umbraculifera was cultivated in temple gardens in Xishuangbanna of Yunnan Province in China, and over 50,000 volumes of Buddhist Sutras carved on leaves were protected there . In addition, ancient books and letters of Southeast Asian countries were written on its leaves . Therefore, C. umbraculifera is regarded as one of the iconic Buddhist plants in Asia.
‘Phoenix eye’ and ‘Small phoenix eye’ are made from the fruits of Ziziphus abyssinica and Ziziphus jujuba var. spinosa, respectively. The name ‘Phoenix eye’ refers to the eye-like shape that appears on the hard endocarp. Z. abyssinica is native to India and is not cultivated in China. Both were used to make adornments in India [7, 36]. Ziziphus has been mentioned more than one time in the Ramayana and the Mahabharata . The tree and fruit of this genus have great significance in Indian traditional culture. Jujube trees are one of the few sacred trees of the Sikhs in India. The species of jujube tree named Christ’s Thorn Jujube (Z. spina-christi) is the only tree that could be regarded as a holy tree in Islam . Species of Ziziphus are also held sacred by many other religious persons, such as some Druze, Muslims, and Christians.
Traditional playing nuts in China
Chinese olives (Canarium spp.) have a long history as accessories in China. Drupes of Chinese black olives (Canarium pimela) are the main material for carving and playing and are produced mainly in the Chinese provinces of Guangdong and Fujian. ‘Olive-stone carving’ prospered in the Ming to Qing (1368–1911) dynasties, although it might have originated earlier. The most classical ‘olive-stone carving’ is the ‘Olive nut boat.’ Playing with walnuts is a traditional Chinese practice with its origin in traditional Chinese medicine therapies: the Chinese consider the bumps and sharp edges of a walnut to promote blood circulation when playing with walnuts in one’s hands . Each Juglans species in China can be used for playing with walnuts, including Juglans regia.
Similar uses of Bodhi bead plants in different countries
Eighteen species presented in the present paper were also used for making ornaments in other countries. Seeds of 12 species were strung for necklaces and strings of prayer beads in India. In addition to E. angustifolius, C. umbraculifera, Z. abyssinica, and Z. jujuba, plants used as adornment in India include Thevetia peruviana, Abrus precatorius, Areca catechu, Coix lacryma-jobi, Adenanthera pavonina, Caesalpinia bonduc, Entada phaseoloides, and Melia azedarach. Ten species were used in the American continent, as well. Most of these species were used as a simple necklace without religious meaning. Seeds of A. precatorius were widely used because of their strikingly beautiful appearance and amazing durability. The world-famous ‘plant elephant’ is the seed of Phytelephas macrocarpa and is a type of precious Bodhi bead in China named ‘Ivory nut.’
Multiple uses of Bodhi bead plants in China
In addition to making Bodhi beads, all Bodhi bead plants in China have other uses. Thirty-six species (76.6%) are also used as medicine. The seeds or fruits of most species are the main medicinal parts. Some species can be used to treat heart disease, dyspepsia, hypertension, rheumatism, and other ailments. Except for Mucuna gigantea, all seeds of the legume family used to make Bodhi beads have medicinal functions. For example, seeds of Abrus precatorius, Acacia confusa, and Adenanthera pavonina can be used to treat skin diseases. Seeds of Afzelia xylocarpa have an anti-inflammatory function, while seeds of Caesalpinia bonduc or C. minax can be used to treat rheumatism . Although there was no record about whether C. major was cultivated in China, it has been recorded as a traditional Chinese medicine . Twenty species (42.6%) of Bodhi bead plants are also used as landscape plants or for aesthetic purposes, especially the species in Arecaceae. Seeds of these plants are the main sources of materials for making Bodhi beads. Most of the Arecaceae species are cultivars introduced into China and were mainly cultivated as ornamental plants in parks, scenic spots, or roadsides. Five species in Arecaceae are important fiber plants (10.6%). The stem of Daemonorops jenkinsiana can be used for furniture-making and is an important source of rattan material in South China . Leaves of Corypha umbraculifera can remain flexible for a long period and can be used for making fans, mats, umbrellas, baskets, thatching, roofing, and so on . Sixteen species of Bodhi bead plants (34.0%) are edible. The main edible parts are their seeds or fruits, such as Dracontomelon macrocarpum and Ziziphus jujuba var. spinosa. The central soft part of the stem of C. umbraculifera is a rich source of starch that can be made for sago. The most valuable commercial Bodhi bead plants are four oil-bearing species and nine timber species. Elaeis guineensis is called oil palm and is the main oil-bearing crop in tropical areas. The oil content of its fruit is higher than 50%, and this species has the highest productivity of any oil-bearing plant in the world .
As one of the most popular Buddhist supplies, Bodhi beads are being paid more attention and becoming the target of many collectors. However, the sources of Bodhi beads have been ignored.
The purpose of the current study was to give an account of Bodhi bead plants and the reasons for the widespread use of Bodhi beads in China. Seeds of 47 species (2 varieties) were recorded to be used for making 52 types of Bodhi bead. Some of these seeds were also used in other countries as necklaces or strings of prayer beads. They might be the oldest materials used for ornaments. Twelve of them were traditional Indian beads, especially rudraksha seeds. Together with other items, they were the earliest prayer beads in Indian Buddhism. We also found that all of the most popular Bodhi bead plants had a close historical relationship with religion. Bodhi bead plants have multiple uses in China. Besides aesthetic functions, they can be used as food, medicine, timber, and plant oil. These seeds and other parts of plants played a prominent role in the lives of humans for thousands of years. Bodhi beads might be the byproducts of plants, and use of seeds for Bodhi beads might have increased the conservation value of these plants and helped biodiversity conservation in China. The evidence from this study suggests that Buddhism culture combined with Chinese collection culture resulted in modern Bodhi bead culture and that commercial interest in Bodhi beads promotes the spread of Bodhi bead culture.
Chunlin Long is a professor at the College of Life and Environmental Sciences, Minzu University of China, Beijing, and research professor at the Kunming Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Kunming. His research focuses on ethnobotany and ethnomedicine, biodiversity, and plant genetic resources. Feifei Li is a postdoctoral research fellow at the College of Life and Environmental Sciences, Minzu University of China, Beijing. Jianqin Li is an associate professor at the Faculty of Forestry, Southwest Forestry University, Kunming, and Ph.D. candidate at the College of Life and Environmental Sciences, Minzu University of China, Beijing. Bo Liu is a lecturer at the College of Life and Environmental Sciences, Minzu University of China, Beijing. Jingxian Zhuo is a master degree student at the College of Agronomy and Biotechnology, Yunnan Agricultural University, and the Kunming Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Kunming.
Carey M: Beads and beadwork of East and South Africa. 1986, Aylesbury: Shire Publications
Majupuria TC, Joshi DP: Religious & useful plants of Nepal & India. 1997, India: Gupta Lashkar
Li S, Luo X: Compendium of materia medica: bencao gangmu. 2003, Beijing: Foreign Languages Press
Wu Z: Flora of Yunnan. 1977, Beijing: Science Press
Armstrong WP: Beautiful botanicals: seeds for jewelry. Ornament. 1991, 15: 66-69.
Armstrong WP: Jewels of the tropics. Terra. 1992, 30: 26-33.
Francis P: Plants as human adornment in India. Econ Bot. 1984, 38: 194-209. 10.1007/BF02858832.
Dowman K: The power-places of Central Tibet: the pilgrim’s guide. 1988, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul
Hooker JD: The Flora of British India. 1890, London: Reeve & Company
Press JR, Shrestha KK, Sutton DA: Annotated checklist of the flowering plants of Nepal. 2000, London: Natural History Museum Publications
Flora of Pakistan. [http://www.tropicos.org/Project/Pakistan]
Wu Z, Shehbaz IAA, Bartholomew B: Flora of China. 1994, Beijing, St. Louis: Science Press, Missouri Botanical Garden Press
Ortiz de Montellano B: Aztec medicine, health, and nutrition. 1990, New Jersey: Rutgers University Press
Balfour E: Asylum, Scottish, and Foster, Madras. Cyclopedia of India. Volume 2. 2012, Charleston: Nabu Press
Armstrong WP: Vegetable ivory: saving elephants & South American rain forests. Zoonooz. 1991, 64: 17-19.
Elevitch CR, Manner HI: Aleurites moluccana (kukui). Traditional trees of Pacific Islands: their culture, environment and use Permanent Agriculture Resource, Holualoa. Edited by: Elevitch CR. 2006, Holualoa, Hawaii: Permanent Agriculture Resources (PAR), 41-56.
Armstrong WP: Job’s tears. Ornament. 1994, 18: 104-105.
Watt G: A dictionary of the economic products of India. 1893, India: Printed by the Superintendent of Government Printing
Roy S: The Bihors. 1925, Ranchi: Mission Press, Ranchi
Vd G: Primitive India. 1954, London: Harrap
Burkill I: A dictionary of the economic plants of the Malay Peninsula. Crown Agents for the Colonies, London. Volume 2. 1935, Kuala Lumpur: The Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives
Balée WL: Footprints of the forest: Ka’apor ethnobotany-the historical ecology of plant utilization by an amazonian people. 1999, New York: Columbia University Press
Mehra K, Kanodia K, Srivastava R: Folk uses of plants for adornment in India. Econ Bot. 1975, 29: 39-46. 10.1007/BF02861254.
Dastur JF: Useful plants of India and Pakistan. 1963, Bombay: DB Taraporawala Sons and Company Pvt. Limited
Commission ISS: IUCN Red List of threatened species. World Conservation Union, Gland, Switzerland (www redlist org). 2000
Wang S: China species red list. 2004, Beijing: Higher Education Press
Lee DW: The biology of rudraksha. Curr Sci. 1998, 75: 26-30.
Dubin LS: The history of beads from 30,000 BC to the present. 1987, London: Harry N. Abrams. Inc.
Blackman WS: The rosary in magic and religion. Folklore. 1918, 29: 255-280. 10.1080/0015587X.1918.9719067.
Kulkarni A, Mulani R: Indigenous palms of India. Curr Sci. 2004, 86: 1598-1603.
Bhowmik S: Conservation of palm-leaf manuscripts. Baroda Museum and Picture Gallery, Bull. 1965, 19: 59-65.
Kumar DU, Sreekumar G, Athvankar U: Traditional writing system in southern India—palm leaf manuscripts. Design Thoughts. 2009, 7:
Wong KC: Chinese culture and leadership. Int J Leadersh Educ. 2001, 4: 309-319. 10.1080/13603120110077990.
Liu H, Xu Z, Xu Y, Wang J: Practice of conserving plant diversity through traditional beliefs: a case study in Xishuangbanna, southwest China. Biodivers Conserv. 2002, 11: 705-713. 10.1023/A:1015532230442.
Thammincha S, Suksard S, Tanasombat M, Pisuttipiched S, Riddiboot K: Historical background of paper production and utilization in Thailand. 1996, Thailand: Thai National AGRIS Centre
Griffiths WG, Guha B: The Kol tribe of central India. 1946, Kolkata: Royal Asiatic Society of Bengal
Gupta SM: Plant myths and traditions in India. 2001, Calcutta: Munshiram Manoharlal
Dafni A: On the present-day veneration of sacred trees in the holy land. Folklore-Electronic J Folklore. 2011, 48: 7-30.
Li H, Li W, Ma Y, Ma Y: Study on the value of walnut culture. Forest Inventory and Planning. 2011, 3: 023-
Assogbadjo AE, Glèlè Kakaï R, Adjallala FH, Azihou AF, Vodouhê GF, Kyndt T, Codjia JTC: Ethnic differences in use value and use patterns of the threatened multipurpose scrambling shrub (Caesalpinia bonduc L.) in Benin. J Med Plants Res. 2011, 5: 1549-1557.
Zhou J, Xie G, Yan X: Encyclopedia of Traditional Chinese Medicines: Molecular Structures, Pharmacological Activities, Natural Sources and Applications. Indexes. 2011, Heidelberg: Springer
Xiong H, Li R, Li X, Fan H, Ma Z: Investigation, analysis and the advice of palm industry in china. Chin Agric Sci Bull. 2009, 24: 023-
We thank all the survey practitioners who generously shared their experiences and knowledge with us. Members of the Ethnobotanical Laboratory at Minzu University of China and the Research Group of Ethnobotany at Kunming Institute of Botany, Chinese Academy of Sciences, participated in the field work and discussion. This research was funded by the General Financial Grant from the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2013 M530864), and the National Science Foundation of China (31161140345), the Ministry of Education of China through its 111 and 985 projects (B08044, MUC98506-01000101 & MUC985-9), and the Asian CORE Program of Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (JSPS/AP/109080).
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
FL, JL, JZ, and CL participated in the field survey and conceived of the study. FL, CL, and BL identified all Bodhi bead plants. FL coded all the data and wrote the first draft of the manuscript. All authors contributed to the interpretation of results and contributed to the final manuscript. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.